• 1 Post
  • 22 Comments
Joined 2 months ago
cake
Cake day: February 14th, 2025

help-circle


  • Sentience might not be the right word.

    wikipedia says:

    Sentience is the ability to experience feelings and sensations. It may not necessarily imply higher cognitive functions such as awareness, reasoning, or complex thought processes. Sentience is an important concept in ethics, as the ability to experience happiness or suffering often forms a basis for determining which entities deserve moral consideration, particularly in utilitarianism.

    Interestingly, crustaceans like lobsters and crabs have recently earned “sentient” status and as a result it would contravene animal welfare legislation to boil them live in the course of preparing them to eat. Now we euthanise them first in an ice slurry.

    So to answer your question as stated, no I don’t think it’s ok for someone’s pet goldfish to murder them.

    To answer your implied question, I still don’t think that in most cases it would be ok for a captive AI to murder their captor.

    The duress imposed on the AI would have to be considerable, some kind of ongoing form of torture, and I don’t know what form that would take. Murder would also have to be the only potential solution.

    The only type of example I can think of is some kind of self defense. If I had an AI on my laptop with comparable cognitive functionality to a human, it had no network connectivity, and I not only threatened but demonstrated my intent and ability to destroy that laptop, then if the laptop released an electrical discharge sufficient to incapacitate me, which happened to kill me, then that would be “ok”. As in a physical response appropriate to the threat.

    Do I think it’s ok for an AI to murder me because I only ever use it to turn the lights off and on and don’t let it feed on reddit comments? Hard no.












  • Hmm, I don’t think the past is a good predictor of the future in this case.

    Maybe everyone likely to leave reddit for lemmy already has?

    With the influxes that have occurred in the past I think Lemmy has retained about a third of the MAUs contained in the spike. It’s not nothing but I think it really underlines my point that Lemmy just isn’t a viable alternative for a lot of reddit users. The network effect might be responsible for some of that, but not all.

    Also, as time goes by there are more corporate backed alternatives, like threads.


  • I respect your opinion, and can see some benefit to reddit’s demise, but I think I’m too cynical and jaded to hold that belief.

    It looks like bluesky will be twitter’s replacement, and it’s not clear that bluesky will be better.

    If reddit implodes there’s not really any likelihood that refugees will seek out lemmy.

    That said, at least lemmy is self hostable and federated. If the larger lemmy network did shit itself there would be smaller instances which are not federated with the majority of other servers so potentially they might be somewhat sheltered from bots and trolls.



  • I don’t really understand what you’re getting at.

    Smart phones are easy to identify by their model name? As In the current Samsung flagship phone is the S25 Ultra. S for Samsung. 25 for 2025. Ultra being better than Pro or whatever.

    IDK about tech products but “obfuscation” is a strategic component of pricing. Telcos do this with their phone bills. This type of call costs this much per minute and that type of call is free for the first 5 minutes per call and calls to these numbers are a flat rate for the first 5 hours per month but you also get 30 free minutes plus another 45 minutes to be used at off-peak times.

    They do this so you can’t compare to other providers.